Why losing a pet can be one of life's most painful experiences, and why the grief that follows deserves to be taken seriously.
You still look towards the door when you come home. You catch yourself checking the time because it's nearly time for their walk. You wake in the night expecting to feel their familiar weight beside you. And then, for a split second, you remember.
For anyone who's lost a much-loved pet, these moments can be devastating. But alongside the sadness, there's often another, less expected emotion: embarrassment: A feeling that perhaps you shouldn't be quite so upset; that other people have experienced far greater losses; that, somehow, you ought to be coping better.
Psychologists have long recognised that the intensity of grief isn't necessarily determined by the nature of the relationship we've lost, but by the significance of the attachment, and for many people, a pet represents one of the most constant, emotionally important relationships in their lives.
It's not just companionship - it's attachment.
Attachment theory offers an important explanation for why losing an animal can be so profoundly unsettling: we form attachments to those who provide comfort, familiarity and a sense of security. Although attachment theory was originally developed to understand human relationships, research suggests that companion animals can fulfil some of these same psychological functions.
Think about the place an animal occupies in someone's life: they're present through changes of job, relationship difficulties, illness, retirement and bereavement; they offer familiar companionship without many of the social demands that accompany human relationships; their presence becomes part of the emotional landscape of home. And there's another dimension to this relationship that's easily overlooked: the experience of being needed.
For someone who lives alone, or whose children have left home, caring for an animal may provide an important sense of purpose and structure. Feeding, walking, grooming and attending to their needs aren't simply chores, they're expressions of a relationship in which someone has a valued role.
When that animal dies, the person may lose not only a companion, but an important part of how they organise their day and understand themselves.
Sometimes, what we're grieving isn't only the animal we've lost, it's the version of our everyday life that existed when they were there.
Why the grief can feel unexpectedly intense
A study published in PLOS One in January 2026 provides an important perspective on the seriousness of pet bereavement. Researchers surveyed 975 adults in the UK and found that, among those who'd experienced both the death of a beloved pet and a human bereavement, 21% identified the loss of their pet as the most distressing bereavement they'd experienced. The research also identified symptoms consistent with prolonged grief among some participants mourning an animal, challenging assumptions that such significant grief reactions are exclusive to human bereavement.
These findings don't mean that every pet loss leads to a mental health problem, or that different kinds of bereavement should be ranked against one another. They demonstrate something more useful: that the depth of someone's emotional response can't reliably be judged from the outside.
Yet pet bereavement is frequently treated differently.
Psychologists describe disenfranchised grief as grief that society doesn't fully recognise or support. Someone who's lost a pet may receive sympathy for a few days, but little acknowledgement of the emotional adjustment that follows. Friends may suggest getting another animal, colleagues may expect business as usual. Even the bereaved person may begin questioning whether their response is excessive.
Research suggests that this lack of social recognition matters. Studies of pet bereavement have found associations between feeling unable to express grief openly and experiencing greater psychological distress. The consequence is a particularly difficult combination: feeling devastated by a loss while simultaneously feeling that you have no right to be devastated.
When grief comes with guilt
For many pet owners, one of the most distressing aspects of bereavement isn't simply the absence of the animal - it's the memory of how their life ended. Unlike most human relationships, caring for a pet can involve making decisions about when their suffering should end.
Even where euthanasia has been recommended by a trusted veterinary professional, owners may find themselves repeatedly questioning the decision. Was it too soon? Had they exhausted every option? Did they prolong their animal's suffering by waiting? Could they have done something differently? These questions can become particularly painful because they're often impossible to answer with certainty.
Research into pet bereavement has identified guilt, regret and perceived involvement in end-of-life decisions as important aspects of the grieving experience. However, euthanasia itself doesn't inevitably lead to worse grief outcomes; recent research has also found associations with lower overall grief severity. The clinically important distinction is between the circumstances of a death and the meaning someone attaches to their own decisions.
Our minds have a tendency to revisit painful events, imagining alternative outcomes in an attempt to make sense of something irreversible. But looking backwards with information and emotional distance that weren't available at the time can create an unfair judgement of our earlier selves.
A useful part of psychological support may involve revisiting these decisions more compassionately, examining what was understood at the time and recognising that acting out of love doesn't always mean having certainty about the outcome.
It's also possible to experience relief that an animal is no longer suffering while simultaneously feeling heartbroken by their absence. These emotions aren't contradictory, and relief isn't evidence of insufficient love.
There's no correct way to grieve
One of the most persistent misconceptions about bereavement is that people move through a predictable sequence of emotional stages. Contemporary grief psychology offers a more nuanced understanding: the dual process model of bereavement describes how people move between confronting their loss and adapting to the practical demands of life without the person, or animal, they've lost.
Someone may spend a morning in tears, enjoy lunch with friends and then feel overwhelmed again when they return to an empty house. This fluctuation isn't a sign that they're grieving incorrectly. It's part of how many people gradually accommodate a significant loss.
Nor does adjusting necessarily mean letting go of the relationship.
Research into continuing bonds suggests that finding ways to preserve a meaningful connection with a deceased companion can be helpful for some people. Keeping photographs, marking anniversaries, sharing stories or continuing a familiar walk can allow the relationship to remain part of someone's life in a different form. The important distinction is whether these memories gradually become a source of comfort or remain predominantly associated with distress. There's no requirement to put away an animal's belongings, adopt another pet or stop feeling sad by a particular date.
When might talking to someone help?
Grief is a natural response to attachment and loss. It isn't, in itself, a psychological disorder, and most people gradually find ways to adjust without formal treatment - but that doesn't mean everyone should have to manage alone.
For some, grief becomes entangled with persistent guilt, anxiety, depression or loneliness. Others find themselves avoiding places or routines associated with their pet, withdrawing from relationships, struggling to sleep or repeatedly reliving upsetting memories of their animal's final days. Sometimes the loss also reawakens earlier bereavements or emotional difficulties that had previously felt manageable.
Psychological support can offer a space to explore these experiences without judgement. Depending on someone's needs, therapy might involve understanding the attachment they've lost, working through distressing memories, addressing self-blame or finding ways to rebuild daily routines and connections. The purpose isn't to persuade someone to stop grieving. It's to help them live with their grief in a way that doesn't progressively diminish the rest of their life, and importantly, a person doesn't need to have developed a diagnosable mental health condition to benefit from a supportive conversation.
Perhaps the most helpful question isn't whether someone should still be grieving, but whether they're getting the support they need, because losing a pet can mean losing a companion, a routine, a source of reassurance and a relationship through which we've both given and received love.
The fact that the relationship was with an animal doesn't make the attachment less meaningful. And it certainly doesn't make the grief less deserving of understanding.
————
At The Soke, our clinicians support people experiencing grief, bereavement and loss. Whether you're struggling with guilt, finding everyday life unexpectedly difficult or simply need somewhere to talk about a relationship that mattered enormously, we're here to listen.
You don't have to wait until things become unbearable to ask for support. And you don't have to justify the depth of your loss.
Contact The Soke at www.thesoke.uk to discuss how we may be able to help.

